ThePaper.in

Political shadow over Tata Group’s governance battle

Suspicious developments behind mega corporate tussle

Ch. Narendra

5 min read

Bombay House, the Tata Group headquarters in Mumbai
Bombay House, the Tata Group headquarters in MumbaiCredit: Arunthomasvtt, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Tata Group is one of India's largest and most prominent multinational conglomerates, known for its Corporate innovation, unique Corporate governance and its social commitment. It is also largest Corporate employer in the country. But, after demise of Ratan Tata, it has been hitting headlines for non-conventional matters.

It is now facing one of its most serious governance battle due to widening gap between Tata Trusts chairman Noel Tata and the Board of Tata Sons, the conglomerate’s principal holding company. While both the factions are seems to be adamant on their way and resorting to extreme steps, the accusations of government interference giving scope for fears of government shadow.

The recent meeting allegedly held between Tata Trusts Chairman Noel Tata, Vice-Chairman Venu Srinivasan and others with the Union Home Minister Amit Shah and Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman giving scope for the Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi to allege that the group was being “criminally destroyed” by the government.

The suspicions are magnified after veteran journalist and The Indian Express columnist Coomi Kapoor wrote of "what many others perceived as a Tamil Brahmin backdoor takeover" of the 150-year-old, quintessentially Parsi business house, Tata Sons, "without purchasing a single share". She also questions the RBI’s “unorthodox” decision on listing and describes the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner’s move as an “insidious” attempt, invoking a “hastily” drafted and legally “ambiguous” amendment to the Act.

Incidentally, Rahul Gandhi is the first politician to comment on the Tata power struggle. He claimed businesses were under pressure from the government. He questioned India Inc.’s silence, and asked why representatives of Tata Trusts and Tata Sons had been hosted at Union Home Minister Amit Shah's residence.

Uproar over Noel Tata’s meeting with Amit Shah

Rahul Gandhi wondered “which ‘legal and commercial matter’ required Tata Trusts and Tata Sons to be hosted at Amit Shah’s residence?”. “When is crony number 1 going to appear in the game and which pieces of Tata is he going to get? Finally, all India’s businesses except 3-4 of your cronies, already hate all of you and don’t need any incitement,” he said.

These developments taken place after an internal Tata Group boardroom dispute regarding the reappointment of N. Chandrasekaran as Chairman of Tata Sons, which Tata Trusts Chairman Noel Tata challenged.

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman was quick in attacking Rahul Gandhi for his comments on Tata Group and accused him of politicising the issue and "casually labelling commercial and legal matters as criminal.” Moreover, she alleged that he was spreading “distrust and toxicity” among business leaders.

However, she failed to address the suspicions raised in business circles after reported meeting of Noel Tata with Amit Shah. It remains to be answered that why the country’s top business leaders should discuss “commercial and legal matters” with the home minister is relevant. Tata Group is known for its values and standards in Corporate norms and is capable of dealing with such crisis.

May not be a mere personality clash

After these developments, many are unable to view the critical tussle within the Tata Group as a mere personality clash between the trust’s chairperson Noel Tata and Tata Sons Executive chairperson N Chandrasekaran. To many observers, the timing raises questions.

The RBI informed in its September 11, 2026 dated letter that Tata Son's application for exemption from the unregistered Core Investment Company (CIC) category, could not be accepted. It is significant to note that it was rejected even after the Tatas had faithfully completed a significant financial restructuring by clearing Rs 21,813 crore of debt in order to ensure that the holding company had no access to public funding.

It must be noted that the Tatas followed the precedent set by Shanghvi Finance, which owns Sun Pharma, and had been permitted to surrender its registration and get regulatory relief in 2023. However, after more than two years the RBI rejected the Tata Sons’ application for exemption from its revised 2022 regulations for the public listing of Tata Sons.

Soon after, the Tata Sons Board from its long-stated position of opposing public listing of the group, decided not to challenge the RBI’s September 11 decision. More interestingly, just a month after Chandrasekaran informing the Board that he would be stepping down as chairperson when his second extended term expired in February, surprisingly on September 17, the Tata Sons board voted to reappoint him, ignoring , objections of the Sir Dorabji Tata and Sir Ratanji Tata trusts that own 66 per cent of Tata Sons.

The third shock came from the Maharashtra charities commissioner, which prohibited the Sir Ratanji Trust from holding a board meeting and taking formal decisions while the commission conducted an inquiry into  charges against the trusts.

Expressing surprise over these developments, a Mumbai based journalist George Mathew wrote in a X post: "While Noel Tata is pushing proposals to keep TataSons unlisted and carve out an exit route for the SP Group, the Tata Sons board has chosen to remain conspicuously silent. The silence is telling". "A corporate house that prides itself on governance and institutional values cannot afford to let a boardroom power struggle hold its future hostage. The Tata saga is far from over. The battle for control is getting uglier", he added.

It may be high-time that Tatas should be left themselves to resolve their issues and the government should ensure that no "motivated interventions" to disrepute one of India’s proud corporate house, be allowed. It is also for their own interest, the Corporate India should stand in preventing any such attempts, from any quarter, for their own interests also.

Sources

  1. Rahul Gandhi on Tata power struggle in X postx.com
  2. Modifying Minority Group.. Coomi Kapoorindianexpress.com
  3. Nirmala Sitharaman slams Rahul Gandhi over his Tata remarktheprint.in
  4. George Mathew at X post on Tata tusslex.com
  5. RBI rejects Tata Sons’ exemption pleafortuneindia.com
  6. Mint: Tata Sons, Shanghvi Finance and the RBIlivemint.com
  7. Board move towards a stock market listing and a fresh five-year term for Chandrasekaran.business-standard.com
  8. Maharashtra State Charity Commissioner directed Tata Trusts to defer the proposed meeting of the board of trusteesnews18.com
  9. Cover photo: Arunthomasvtt, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commonscommons.wikimedia.org

Share this story

Enjoyed this? Get new stories in your inbox.

One email on Mondays with the week's new stories. Free, and one click to unsubscribe.

About the writer

Ch. Narendra

Freelance Journalist

A journalist by profession, worked with New Indian Express Group for a long time, besides some other media organizations, based in Hyderabad, presently a freelance journalist.

Writes about Journalism, Business, Politics, Education

More from Ch. Narendra

View profile
More in Business

Your stories deserve an audience

Publish your work on ThePaper.in, build a professional portfolio, and get discovered by publishers looking for writers.