Special Parliament Session to debate SIR sparks row
Shah offers a special session on SIR, but the opposition questions his record in Parliament
5 min read

Strongly attacking Congress-led INDIA bloc’s "vote chori" allegations and nation-wide protests seeking resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Union Home Minister Amit Shah has challenged Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi for a debate on SIR and other issues related to the Election Commission, in the Parliament. This has sparked a fresh political row between the ruling BJP and the main opposition party Congress.
The fresh political confrontation comes against the backdrop of continuing disagreements between them over electoral roll revisions and other national issues. Rahul Gandhi has been repeatedly raising questions about the Election Commission's handling of voter lists, particularly the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise. Rejecting all such accusations, the BJP is challenging the Congress's position.
Amit Shah said that the government is ready to convene a special session of Parliament on the issue and dared Congress leader Rahul Gandhi to debate the matter in the House. The BJP has initiated nation-wide padayatras with a slogan 'Save Democracy, Remove Anarchy' as a counter to Congress led-INDIA bloc's rally in Delhi on November 1.
Leading BJP's padayatra in Hyderabad on November 2, Amit Shah said: " He (Rahul) holds the Constitution in hand, but doesn't respect the Constitution. Rahul ji, you don't allow Parliament to run. Be it EVMs, SIR, infiltrators, I challenge you from Hyderabad. We are ready to convene a special session of Parliament. Come for debate." He further expressed confidence that if a Parliament session is held, Prime Minister Narendra Modi will shred Congress into pieces, accusing the Congress of wanting to be in the limelight.
Later, on November 5, leading a similar padayatra in Karnal of Haryana, Amit Shah repeated his challenge stating, “I want to challenge Rahul Gandhi directly. You challenge PM Narendra Modi to a discussion? If you want a discussion, just write a letter to the prime minister. We are ready to convene a special session of Parliament to discuss the SIR exercise.”
Rahul Gandhi seeks open debate with PM Modi
But, a day after, Rahul Gandhi rejected Amit Shah's challenge to debate inside Parliament or have the government convene a special session. He said that PM Modi should face him directly in an open debate rather than shifting the venue or terms.Two days later, the Congress leader renewed his challenge for a public debate, urging Union Home Minister Amit Shah to convince PM Modi to accept the invitation.
Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman coming in support of Amit Shah, rejected Rahul Gandhi’s preference for an open debate and asserted that Parliament is the venue for such debates. She asked in an X post, “Rahul ji, you ask the Prime Minister to choose a venue for a debate. There is already one: Parliament, where you happen to be the LoP. Just yesterday @AmitShah offered a special session to debate SIR and EVMs. Why not show the same enthusiasm for a debate in Parliament that you show while issuing challenges on social media?”
Coming to the aid of Rahul Gandhi, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge challenged Prime Minister Modi to face questions on the alleged “vote chori” and accept the open debate challenges issued by Rahul Gandhi. Moreover, he lamented that PM Modi had no answers to the allegations of electoral manipulation and should agree to Gandhi’s challenge to debate issues including the prime minister’s alleged “foreign connections”.
In a post in X, he accused the Prime Minister that “He has NO answer on Vote Chori and the Open Challenge by Shri @RahulGandhi to discuss how he mortgaged Indian interests to Foreign powers!”. He further alleged that “ You don’t come to the Parliament. You have not done a SINGLE OPEN PRESS CONFERENCE, it’s time you came for a DEBATE. Come forward, Face Questions. Tell the Nation why did you indulge in VOTE CHORI !!”
Winter session washed away
Interestingly, Parliament winter session was practically washed away without a meaningful debates in December, 2025, as the government refused to budge to the opposition demand for a debate on SIR. On December 10, 2025 Amit Shah wondered how SIR could be discussed in Parliament when the Election Commission of India is responsible for the exercise?
Replying to the debate on electoral reforms in the Lok Sabha, Amit Shah asserted that “… such a discussion cannot take place in this House because the responsibility for Special Intensive Revision (SIR) lies with the Election Commission, and the Commission does not work under the Government”.
Congress general secretary in charge of communications Jairam Ramesh ridiculed the challenge: "Last year, when the combined Opposition wanted a debate on SIR, he had refused, saying SIR was the prerogative of the Election Commission."
Amit Shah avoided monsoon session
Moreover, the opposition pointed out that Amit Shah avoided Parliament during monsoon session in July, 2026, after the opposition demanded a statement from Amit Shah on the police excesses and violence during the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP)-led Sansad Chalo march on July 20th.
Even the Supreme Court intervened and formed a five-member High-Powered Expert Committee (HPEC) in August under the chairmanship of former Supreme Court judge, justice (retd) R Subhash Reddy, to submit a factual report. The top court has directed the panel to look into allegations of harassment and molestation - particularly those involving female protesters - be treated as a priority.
However, as home minister Amit Shah continued to remain absent in parliament, despite opposition parties demanding both inside and outside the house that he should make a statement on why the Delhi Police and the Rapid Action Force – both of which respond to the Union home ministry, used force, including tear gas, against protesting youth.
After three weeks, responding to the opposition’s demand, he dismissed their concerns amid continuous disruptions. “The Opposition is not letting the Parliament function. So what is the point of going to the House?” the minister asked while speaking to the media. His challenge now has raised questions, from the opposition, about how genuine the offer of a parliamentary debate is.
The previous, 17th Lok Sabha (2019-2024) held 274 sittings, the fewest of any full-term Lok Sabha, according to PRS Legislative Research.
Sources
- Amit Shah Challenge to Rahul Gandhihindustantimes.com
- Amit Shah repeat his challengenewindianexpress.com
- Rahul Gandhi for a open debateinstagram.com
- Nirmala Sitharamanx.com
- Mallikharjuna Khargex.com
- Amit Shah in Lok Sabhandtv.com
- Jairam Rameshdailypioneer.com
- Supreme Court setup a panelndtv.com
- Amit Shah on attending Parliamentthesouthfirst.com
- PRS Legislative Researchprsindia.org
- Cover photo: BJP, via bjp.orgbjp.org
Enjoyed this? Get new stories in your inbox.
One email on Mondays with the week's new stories. Free, and one click to unsubscribe.
About the writer
Freelance Journalist
A journalist by profession, worked with New Indian Express Group for a long time, besides some other media organizations, based in Hyderabad, presently a freelance journalist.
Writes about Journalism, Business, Politics, Education







